A list of our favorite restaurants in and around Herkimer, NY. We hand-pick these because we’ve eaten there, sent guests there, and they consistently deliver. Hours and details can change, so call ahead when in doubt.
Herkimer, NY — at the inn
Stone Soup American Bistro
$$
Global-Inspired American
Offers a distinctive menu with global influences (French, Japanese, Italian) and a great selection of local beers.
Waterfront Grille
$$
American · Waterfront Views
Offers a varied menu in a casual but pleasant setting right on the Mohawk River.
PK’s Pub
$$
Upscale Pub Fare
Excellent burgers, entrees, and a relaxed atmosphere.
Godfather’s Hideout
$$
Authentic Utica-Style Italian
Known for excellent homemade Italian food and classics like Chicken Riggies and Utica Greens.
Salvatore’s Pizzeria and Restaurant
$$
Italian · Pizza
Casual neighborhood Italian and pizza spot on West German Street, a short walk from the inn.
Newer Herkimer spot for fresh smoothies, bowls, burgers, and globally-inspired bites like Sweet Thai chicken and Chicken Al Pastor empanadas.
Frankfort, NY — ~10 min west
Heelpath Brewery Co.
$$
Brewery · Craft Beer
Central New York craft brewery on the Erie Canal with 12 beers on tap. Open since 2019; 80% of ingredients sourced locally from New York State. Casual canalside seating.
Family-owned and operated since 1939. Casual American dining with Italian, Greek, and Polish specialties. Known for baby back ribs and house-made pies and desserts.
Little Falls, NY — ~15 min east
Trattoria Giorgio
$$
Authentic Italian
A fine Italian restaurant specializing in authentic Italian cuisine since 1996, offering a cozy and elegant dining experience.
Beardslee Castle
$$$
Inspired American Cuisine
A c.1860 limestone castle in the heart of the historic Mohawk Valley, now in its 32nd year as a chef-owned destination restaurant. Intimate dining on the main floor with an extensive wine cellar; the Dungeon bar & grill offers casual lighter fare and 100+ craft beverages. Monthly Murder Mystery Dinner Theater shows in the banquet room.
Utica, NY — ~20 min west
Ocean Blue
$$$
Seafood · Steakhouse
Located on the 6th floor with beautiful views of downtown. Excellent for high-quality seafood and steaks, and a great cocktail menu.
The Tailor and the Cook
$$$
American Fine Dining
Focuses on farm-to-table cuisine with creative dishes and an excellent wine list in an intimate setting.
Roman’s at Valley View
$$$
Italian-American Fine Dining
Italian-American tradition meets contemporary elegance with panoramic views. Handcrafted dishes like grilled octopus, beef short-rib pappardelle, and surf & turf.
mōtus
$$$
Modern American · Gastropub
A modern American restaurant and gastropub in downtown Utica with a seasonal, locally-sourced menu that changes throughout the year.